Cookies & Sweets

Cookies & Sweets

We have developed quite a local following for our Cookies, Muffins and Other Sweet Treats. Not everything is available every day. So call ahead to find out the day’s offerings. Or we are always happy to take special orders if you can give us a little notice.


Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie
La Bodega Trail Mix Cookie
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Coconut Almond Macaroon
Cranberry Pistachio Ice Box Cookie
Almond Butter Cookie

Sweet Treats

Banana Nut Bread
Sticky Buns
Cinnamon Swirl
Pumpkin Banana Pecan Bread
Muffin of the Day
Espresso Brownies
Assorted Scones

Special Orders

Mango Triangle
Mexican Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Bread Pudding
Mango and Cranberry Bread Pudding
Carrot Cake

Key West Chef

About our Bakery

Select ingredients and chef-inspired preparations make our soups, salads and hand-crafted sandwiches an Old Town Key West tradition. Served with the best bread on the island. Please let us know if you have any allergies.